Skip to content 
In the extensive literature of leadership development books, few deliver wisdom as uniquely and profoundly as Robert N. Tullar’s “Why Leaders Fall: A Journey Through The Redwoods.” Unlike conventional leadership manuals, Tullar’s work draws inspiration from one of nature’s most awe-inspiring creations—the mighty redwood trees. These towering giants are more than just forest icons; they become vivid metaphors for leadership strength, vulnerability, balance, and recovery.
Through an effective narrative rooted in decades of personal experience and spiritual insight, Tullar crafts a fresh blueprint for developing leaders who not only rise with strength but also recover with grace. This blog explores the nature-based strategies and insights presented in the book.
Nature’s Metaphor: Redwoods as Models in Leadership Books
In “Why Leaders Fall,” Tullar asks a powerful question: What makes a towering leader fall, and what happens to those standing nearby? He parallels this question with the fall of a redwood tree—an event that shakes the entire forest, often damaging many smaller trees along its path.
This analogy forms the backbone of one of the most insightful books about leadership development, showing how leaders are deeply interconnected with those around them. Just like redwoods, leaders rely on a complex root system—a combination of relationships, values, and emotional strength. When this system weakens, collapse is not only possible but inevitable.
Through this lens, Tullar doesn’t just warn against failure. He teaches how to prevent the fall, repair after it, and grow stronger because of it—a philosophy that places his book among the most effective books to develop leadership skills.
Root Systems: The Foundation of Resilient Leaders
A core concept in Tullar’s framework is the importance of developing a strong “root system.” In the natural world, redwoods flourish because their roots stretch far and intertwine with others. Their survival depends not on depth, but on interconnectedness.
Tullar applies this directly to leadership: no one leads alone. Successful leaders cultivate a support system of peers, mentors, family, and trusted colleagues. These external roots are complemented by internal ones—character, integrity, humility, and emotional intelligence.
In many leadership development books, root systems are often overlooked in favor of goal-setting and strategy. But in “Why Leaders Fall,” root-building is the strategy. Leaders are encouraged to:
- Build diverse and dependable relationships.
- Strengthen personal values.
- Avoid isolation and overdependence on personal strength.
These principles make Tullar’s work not just a guide but one of the most impactful books for developing leadership skills—especially for those seeking to lead with depth and authenticity.
Storms, Fire, and Falling: The Value of Adversity in Leadership
Unlike many idealistic portrayals found in other texts, Tullar confronts the reality that even the tallest, most well-rooted leaders can fall. His work provides one of the most honest reflections on failure in the realm of books about leadership development. He draws attention to:
- The Storms:
Unexpected challenges that test leaders.
- The Fire:
Crises that burn away what’s weak or unnecessary.
- The Fall:
The collapse that impacts not just the leader but everyone around them.
However, Tullar doesn’t stop at the fall. His most valuable contribution may be his detailed guidance on what happens after a leader collapses. In his words, “Unlike the redwood, which stays down once it falls, we as humans can rise again.” Through strategies such as:
- Honest self-reflection,
- Reconnection with trusted allies,
- Realignment of values,
- And gradual restoration of trust
…leaders can return stronger than ever. These recovery methods set his work apart from many leadership development books that focus only on success. Tullar gives readers hope, steps, and structure for getting back up.
Why This Is One of the Best Books for Real-World Leaders
What elevates “Why Leaders Fall: A Journey Through The Redwoods” above many others is its real-world relatability. Tullar isn’t speaking from a pedestal—he shares his own stories of imbalance, overwork, disconnection, and the impact those decisions had on his family and professional life.
This vulnerability creates a connection with the reader and brings depth to his strategies. While many books about leadership development dwell on tactics and high-performance routines, Tullar focuses on humanity. Key takeaways that make this book one of the best books to develop leadership skills include:
- Leadership begins at home—a balance between work and family is not optional.
- Leaders must invest in personal and spiritual growth, not just professional development.
- Strengthening those around you strengthens your own leadership foundation.
- Prioritizing mentorship—both giving and receiving—is essential.
These are not lofty ideals. They are practical, tested, and deeply applicable across industries, ages, and roles.
The Repair Process: A Unique Strategy
Perhaps the most original and needed insight in “Why Leaders Fall” is the chapter on repairing your root system. Tullar likens fallen redwoods that nourish saplings around them to leaders who rebuild others even after personal failure. He emphasizes:
- Accountability:
Owning your mistakes without defensiveness.
- Adaptability:
Relearning how to grow with new roots and new support systems.
- Legacy Mindset:
Accepting that your leadership is not just about the present, but about the impact you leave behind.
While the fall may damage your reputation or team, it can also give birth to new growth if handled with maturity and grace. This restorative viewpoint is rarely seen in even the best leadership development books, and it’s what makes Tullar’s perspective so refreshing.
Balance, Values, and Vision: Lasting Lessons in Books About Leadership Development
In his final chapters, Tullar turns his focus to sustainability in leadership. Not environmental sustainability, but personal and relational sustainability. Leaders must not only build but also maintain their leadership ecosystems. He encourages:
- Using daily planners not just for meetings, but for family and personal time.
- Treating home life with the same discipline as business life.
- Nurturing core beliefs, just as one would nurture a business vision.
By grounding success in personal wellness, spiritual depth, and relational health, “Why Leaders Fall” proves itself one of the most holistically wise books about leadership development available today.
Conclusion: Learning from the Forest to Lead in the World
Robert N. Tullar’s work stands as a profound testament to the power of humility, restoration, and deeply rooted leadership. In a market saturated with technique-heavy manuals, his book is a rare mix of metaphor, experience, and strategy that speaks to the soul of leadership.
For anyone seeking leadership development books that go beyond metrics and truly develop the person behind the leader, this is a must-read. It’s not just about how to stand tall—it’s about how to fall, rise, and grow stronger than ever.
Among the best leadership development books, Tullar’s work reminds us that leadership is not just a position—it’s a relationship. It’s a root system. It’s a forest.
