Leadership continues to evolve alongside changing workplaces, social dynamics, and global challenges. The modern leader is expected to be adaptive, collaborative, emotionally intelligent, and resilient — qualities that cannot be mastered overnight. This is why reading thoughtfully written leadership literature remains one of the most effective ways to develop insight and perspective.
Among the best leadership books 2026, one title that offers a distinctive and reflective approach is Why Leaders Fall: A Journey Through The Redwoods by Robert N. Tullar. Rather than presenting leadership as a collection of techniques or formulas, Tullar explores leadership through the metaphor of redwood forests — emphasizing connection, resilience, and ecosystem thinking.
This blog explores why this novel stands out among the best leadership books, how its philosophy reshapes leadership understanding, and what lessons aspiring leaders can carry forward.
The Changing Definition of Leadership in 2026
Leadership today extends far beyond organizational titles. Students, entrepreneurs, community members, team contributors, and creatives all encounter moments requiring leadership decisions. Authority is no longer the defining feature — influence, responsibility, and relational impact are. Readers exploring the books in 2026 increasingly seek guidance on:
- Leading without positional power
- Navigating uncertainty
- Building collaborative environments
- Sustaining personal resilience
- Recovering from leadership setbacks
Robert Tullar’s work directly addresses these modern concerns by shifting focus from leader personality to leader connectivity.
Why “Why Leaders Fall” Stands Out Among the Best Leadership Books 2026
Many leadership books center on how to succeed. Tullar instead asks a more revealing question: why do leaders fail?
This inversion of perspective provides depth rarely seen in leadership literature. By examining collapse, instability, and recovery, the book offers readers a fuller understanding of leadership reality. Within discussions of the 2026 leadership books, this work is notable for three reasons:
1. Ecosystem Leadership Thinking
Leadership is framed as participation in a system rather than individual performance.
2. Failure as Instruction
Failure is treated as a source of learning rather than a sign of inadequacy.
3. Follower-Centered Perspective
The book explores how individuals navigate environments where leaders falter.
These dimensions create a reflective leadership experience that resonates strongly with readers searching for the best books about leadership 2026.
The Redwood Metaphor: A New Leadership Lens
The central metaphor of the book is the redwood forest. Redwood trees grow extraordinarily tall yet maintain shallow roots that interconnect with neighboring trees. Stability emerges from connection rather than depth alone. This metaphor reveals several leadership truths:
1. Interdependence Creates Strength
Just as redwoods rely on neighboring root systems, leaders rely on networks of peers, mentors, team members, and supporters.
2. Protection Requires Community
The bark and forest environment shield trees from external threats, mirroring how relationships protect leaders from burnout and isolation.
3. Diversity Enhances Stability
Different tree species contribute to forest health, reflecting how varied perspectives strengthen leadership environments.
Readers examining the leadership books often find this metaphor memorable because it transforms leadership from abstract theory into a visual understanding.
Leadership as a Universal Human Experience
One of Tullar’s core ideas is that leadership is universal. Every individual influences others at some point — within families, teams, classrooms, or communities. This perspective aligns with emerging leadership conversations found across top leadership books 2026, which emphasize:
- Informal leadership
- Shared leadership models
- Collective responsibility
By redefining leadership as influence rather than position, the book invites readers to recognize their leadership potential regardless of job title.
The Responsibility–Accountability–Authority Progression
A notable conceptual framework presented in the book is the progression from responsibility to accountability to authority.
-
Responsibility
Leaders accept tasks and roles impacting others.
-
Accountability
They answer for outcomes and decisions.
-
Authority
Through consistent accountability, trust emerges, granting authentic authority.
This progression highlights that authority is relationally earned rather than structurally assigned — a concept that positions the book firmly among the best leadership books 2026.
Understanding Why Leaders Fall
The diagnostic exploration of leadership failure is a defining strength of the book. Several patterns emerge:
-
Isolation
Leaders who withdraw from support networks become vulnerable to misjudgment and stress.
-
Narrow Relationship Circles
Limiting connections to peers reduces perspective diversity and support capacity.
-
Neglect of Small Responsibilities
Minor overlooked tasks accumulate into larger systemic weaknesses.
-
Misinterpretation of Pressure
Viewing adversity solely as a threat rather than a growth opportunity undermines resilience.
These insights reinforce that leadership collapse often results from gradual erosion rather than sudden events — a theme that distinguishes this book within discussions of the best books for leadership skills 2026.
Building Leadership Root Systems
If disconnection leads to failure, connection becomes prevention. The book outlines practical ways leaders cultivate root systems.
Developing Relationships
Investing in mentors, colleagues, and team members.
Utilizing Support
Actively seeking input and assistance rather than carrying burdens alone.
Repairing Connections
Acknowledging mistakes and rebuilding trust where relationships have weakened.
This maintenance mindset positions relationships as infrastructure — requiring ongoing attention, much like organizational processes.
Surviving When Leaders Fail
A rare dimension of Tullar’s work is its focus on individuals operating under ineffective leadership. The book encourages readers to:
- Recognize early warning signs
- Expand personal support networks
- Strengthen peer relationships
- Accept that leader failure is sometimes inevitable
These lessons empower readers not only to lead but to remain resilient within imperfect leadership environments — contributing to its reputation among inspiring leadership books 2026.
Crisis as a Leadership Revealer
Another central theme is the revealing nature of crisis. Difficult circumstances expose leadership strengths, weaknesses, and relational dynamics. The book emphasizes:
- Crisis does not create character but reveals it
- Support networks become visible during adversity
- Meaning-making transforms hardship into growth
Such reflections resonate with contemporary leadership conversations that emphasize adaptive leadership and emotional resilience.
Servant Leadership Foundations
The philosophical tone of the book aligns with servant leadership principles — leaders exist to serve and support those they lead.
This orientation appears through:
- Emphasis on helping others succeed
- Recognition of leadership responsibility
- Focus on relational well-being
By prioritizing service over status, the book contributes to the broader shift toward human-centered leadership seen across the best leadership books 2026.
Practical Lessons for Aspiring Leaders
Readers can translate the book’s reflections into everyday practice.
-
Cultivate Diverse Connections
Engage with individuals across roles, perspectives, and experiences.
-
Seek Feedback Regularly
External insight strengthens decision quality.
-
Recognize Early Signs of Disconnection
Isolation often precedes leadership challenges.
-
Normalize Failure Conversations
Learning environments reduce fear and promote growth.
-
Invest in Community
Leadership strength is multiplied through collective capacity.
These actionable insights reinforce why it is frequently highlighted when discussing leadership books.
Emotional and Reflective Value of the Book
Beyond conceptual lessons, the book offers emotional reassurance. Leaders often experience self-doubt, uncertainty, and pressure. By presenting failure as a shared human experience, Tullar reduces stigma and encourages reflection.
Readers exploring the leadership books of 2026 frequently seek not only knowledge but encouragement — and this book provides both.
Who Should Read This Book?
The book’s accessibility and reflective style make it suitable for diverse readers:
- Emerging leaders seeking foundational insight
- Experienced leaders reflecting on legacy
- Educators teaching leadership concepts
- Team members navigating leadership transitions
- Individuals interested in personal growth
Its broad relevance strengthens its position among the best leadership books of 2026. If readers want to read more about knowledge and leadership skills, they are encouraged to read our blog “Best Leadership Books to Read: Essential Guides for Every Leader.”
Expanding Your Leadership Library: Leadership Books of 2026
While Why Leaders Fall offers a foundational framework for leadership resilience, readers seeking additional perspectives from the broader leadership books of 2026 conversation may also explore:
- The Leadership Edge by Hayley Paige
- Becoming Better Business Leaders by Mike Hackney
- Connect Lead Succeed by Dixie Maria Carlton
These titles complement the lessons found in Tullar’s work for readers wanting expanded viewpoints. However, the heart of this blog — and the strongest foundation among the best leadership books 2026 — remains the Redwood leadership model.
More books beyond just 2026 and insightful leadership lessons, visit this blog “Books on Leadership Principles: The Ultimate Guide for Leaders.”
Lasting Impact of Redwood Leadership Thinking
Perhaps the book’s most enduring contribution is the shift from leader-centric thinking to ecosystem thinking. Instead of asking:
-
How strong is the leader?
The book encourages asking:
-
How strong is the leadership network?
This reframing transforms leadership development into community development, relationship development, and resilience development simultaneously.
Such a perspective explains why it continues to appear in conversations surrounding the best leadership books of 2026.
Conclusion
Leadership remains one of the most complex and consequential human endeavors. It influences organizations, communities, families, and societies. For aspiring leaders seeking meaningful guidance, reflective leadership literature offers invaluable insight.
Why Leaders Fall: A Journey Through The Redwoods stands out among the best leadership books 2026 for its thoughtful metaphor, honest exploration of failure, and emphasis on relational strength. By presenting leadership as an interconnected ecosystem, Robert Tullar provides readers with a perspective that is both humbling and empowering.
Ultimately, the book reminds us that leadership success is rarely the achievement of a single individual. Like towering redwoods, leaders rise highest when they are most deeply connected. For anyone exploring the best leadership books in 2026, this work offers a powerful invitation to rethink leadership — not as solitary performance, but as shared growth within a living network of relationships.